How should I handle refunds, returns and exchanges?
Write one clear policy that says what can come back, for how long, in what condition, who pays the return shipping, and whether the customer gets a refund, an exchange or store credit, then follow it the same way every time. Offer an exchange or store credit first when it fits, because it keeps the sale. Keep money decisions with a person: refund once the item is back, or when an order is cancelled before it ships, and log every reason so you can fix what causes them.
What the policy should say
- The window: how many days after delivery a return can start, such as 30.
- The condition: unused, with tags, in the original packaging, and what can never come back, such as final sale or opened consumables.
- Who pays the return label: free returns, a flat fee, or the label's cost taken from the refund.
- What the customer gets: a refund to the original payment, an exchange for another size or color, or store credit.
- The steps: how to start a return, where to send it, and when the refund or exchange goes out.
- The reason: a short list on every return (too small, too big, damaged, not as described, changed my mind), so you can see what to fix.
A worked example
Example: a made-up apparel store, not a real business.
In September 2026 it shipped 800 orders and got 50 return requests: 28 for the wrong size, 9 from customers who changed their mind, 7 that arrived damaged and 6 that were not as described.
- Wrong size: an exchange offered first. 20 took it and 8 asked for a refund.
- Changed their mind: store credit offered. 4 took it and 5 asked for a refund.
- Damaged: 7 replacements sent, with photos kept for the carrier claim.
- Not as described: 6 refunds, and the product photos were reshot so the color reads true.
- Result: 31 of the 50 stayed a sale, and 19 were refunded once the items came back.
- Requests
- 50 of 800
- Kept as a sale
- 31
- Refunded
- 19
It depends
It depends on your products, your margins and where your customers are. Adjust when:
- Some items cannot come back. Say clearly what is final sale, on the product page and in the policy.
- The item is cheap. A return label can cost more than the item. A refund or replacement without the return can cost less.
- Orders are made to order or preordered. A cancel before production is different from a return after delivery. Say both.
- Customers are abroad. Return shipping and duties make returns expensive. For a low-value order, a refund or credit without the item can cost less.
- A few customers return a lot. Limit returns per customer, or require the item back before any refund.
- The order came from a marketplace. Amazon and other marketplaces set their own return rules for orders placed there.
What Arxos does here
Arxos answers return questions from your policy and the real order, and refunds wait for a person's click, with one exception: if your team turns it on, the store chat can cancel a verified buyer's unshipped order inside your return window, refund included. A shipped order is refunded by you, in Shopify.
- Answers in your voiceThe chat on your store answers from your products, your policies and your past answers.
- Brings you only the hard onesAnything with money or judgment waits for you, with the reply already written.
- Free spare parts, draftedA part you send for free becomes a $0 draft order in Shopify for you to complete. Arxos never charges anyone.
Connect your Shopify store and Arxos does this for you, every day.
Answers return questions from your policy, and brings you the ones with money.
14 days free. Set up in minutes. Cancel anytime.
Questions owners ask
What is a fair return window?
Long enough to receive and try the product. Thirty days after delivery is a common choice, and a longer window over the holidays covers gifts.
Should I charge for return shipping?
It depends on your margins and your return rate. Free returns make buying feel safer but cost you on every return. A flat fee or a label taken from the refund keeps returns for real problems. Keeping exchanges free keeps the sale.
When should I refund: at drop-off or when the item arrives?
When it arrives and you have checked it, which protects you from empty boxes and worn items. A refund at drop-off is faster for the customer. Save it for customers and products with a clean record.
Should I refund to the card or give store credit?
Give what your policy promises. Store credit keeps the money in your store, so offer it first, but a refund to the original payment must stay available wherever your policy or the law says so.